123telugu.com :

Nagarjuna deserves a hearty applause for having the courage to take up this role and he has managed to pull it off with conviction.This film will appeal immensely to Sai Baba
devotees and it will be a good watch for casual movie lovers. Watch the film without any expectations and immerse yourself in Sai Baba’s spirituality.

Rating: 3.5/5

Greatandhra.com:

The film is made with a chain of miracles but will not hold any story line. If proper home work and research was done, then the film would have touched a higher mark. Whatever the positive
result the film yields, it will be merely by the grace and pulling factor of today’s powerful God Shirdi Sai Baba.

Rating: 3.25/5

Gulte.com:

Shirdi Sai will appeal to the target audience and has good chances to make good money at the box office. Watch it if you are devotee of Shirdi Sai.

Rating: 3.5/5

Idlebrain.com:

The film Sai Baba attempts to tell the world about the making of an enlightened man called Sai Baba who is revered as a God today. Nagarjuna is the major highlight of the film and he convinces us all as Sai Baba. You may watch Shirdi Sai with an academic interest.